Introduction
If you're wondering about buying an old flute from an
antique shop or internet site, you do need to make sure it's at the pitch
you want to play at. You can get a rough idea from the length of the
flute, from end to end, or the "sounding length" of the flute,
from middle of the embouchure hole to the far end. This page lists
the lengths of the most usual types of flutes you might encounter.
Overall length
This is perhaps the least useful of all, but one that is
given most often.
Sounding Length
This is the distance from the middle of the embouchure
hole to the end of the flute. Again, not particularly helpful as
different makers allowed different amounts of spare length on the tuning
slide. It's really an indicator of the highest pitch a flute can
play, not where it's best tuned.
McGee Indicator, C# to D#
I prefer this measurement as it tells us more about the
tuning of the body and foot of the flute than the others. C# and D#
were chosen after a lot of consideration - see:
C# to D# - a more useful indicator of flute pitch?
You probably won't see these listed in advertisements, but it's a good idea
to ask.
[Historical note - I actually have since seen these
measurements included in some advertisements!]
Anglo-centric, 19th Century
The lengths below are mostly for English flutes in the
19th century, as that is my area and period of speciality. I'm happy
to include figures for other kinds of flutes if supplied.
Pitch naming conventions
A lot of confusion arises in the naming of flutes by
pitch. The modern practice of naming the flute leads to immense
problems when applied to earlier instruments. I'm using the
time-honoured convention, calling the flute by its "6 fingers
covered" note. If there is an extension below that note, I also
give the lowest note achieved by that extension. So an 8-key conical
flute is a D flute with C foot.
The expression High Pitch refers to the period in England
(2nd half 19th century) where playing pitch reached 452 to 455 Hz, before
being pulled back to 440 Hz.
Cylindrical Multi-key flutes
I've made a separate table for cylindrical multi-key
flutes, by which I mean Boehm, Carte, Radcliff, cylindrical Clinton
flutes, etc. Old system cylindrical bore flutes seem to fit better
among the conicals (historically) and have been left there for now.
Range versus Single value
You'll notice I've given a range for some and a single
value for others. That was in order to get the chart up
quickly. If you find your flute falls outside the range, let me know
and I'll expand it, thus making the chart more accurate and more useful to
everybody.
Imperial conversions
The lengths above are given in mm. If you prefer to
think in Imperial, divide these by 25.4. If you'd rather cm, divide
by 10.
Concert Flutes
|
Concert
flutes |
Overall Length |
Sounding Length |
McGee Indicator
C# to Eb |
1 - 4 key concert flute, D |
610 |
530 |
257-262 |
|
|
|
|
6 and 8-key concert flute,
D with C foot, early 19th C |
675-677 |
595-603 |
261-264 |
Ditto, Improved style |
638-660 |
567-585 |
252-258 |
Ditto, Perfected style |
650-660 |
567-578 |
244-249 |
|
|
|
|
8 key cylindrical old system |
658 |
569 |
249 |
ditto, High Pitch body |
652 |
574 |
240 |
|
|
|
|
Conical multi-key flutes,
Clinton, Carte, etc |
647-660 |
574-577 |
254-256 |
Conical & old system flutes in
other pitches
|
Conical & old system
flutes in other pitches |
Overall Length |
Sounding Length |
McGee Indicator
C# to Eb |
D piccolo, conical |
302-308 |
252-258 |
119-123 |
|
|
|
|
Eb piccolo, conical |
|
|
|
Bb band flute |
390 |
328 |
152 |
F band flute with F foot |
|
|
|
F band flute with Eb foot |
565 |
490 |
210 |
ditto, High Pitch |
490 |
410 |
189 |
Eb band flute |
605 |
527 |
236 |
Bb bass band flute,
4 key with Bb foot |
748 |
656 |
295.5 |
Bb bass band flute
6-8 key with Ab foot |
819 |
729 |
303 |
Cylindrical multi-key flutes
|
Cylindrical multi-key flutes |
Overall Length |
Minimum Emb to A |
Sounding Length |
McGee Indicator
C# to Eb |
Boehm cylinder flute,
Nos #1
& 2 |
|
319 |
590.5 |
251.5 |
Ditto, early French
(Lot, Godfroy) |
|
315-324 |
584 - 595 |
251.4 - 254.4 |
Rudall Carte,
early model |
639 |
310 |
582 |
253 |
Rudall Carte, later High Pitch |
654 |
312 |
579 |
249 |
Rudall Carte, 1940's |
678 |
324 |
599 |
259 |
US Boehm style flute, 1970's |
672 |
326 |
603 |
258 |
Powell Cooper scale, #4434 |
670 |
327 |
598 |
256.4 |
Modern scale
according to Wye |
|
|
|
255 |
Revised Cooper Scale, A=441
Bennett, Spell & Wye, March 2011 |
|
|
|
253.7 |
Interesting to note that Rudall's early cylinder flutes appear to have
been tuned (in the body) similarly to Boehm's, but the speaking length is
considerably reduced. This appears consistent with English habits of
the times as illustrated by conical flutes - tune low, but provide a short
head on a long tuning slide to permit playing at much higher pitch.
Later, at the heights of the High Pitch lunacy, the body scaling was
shortened considerably, to permit playing in tune at high
pitch. We can see about the same change in sounding length, so no
further change to the head occurred here.
Another factor affecting sounding length is playing style
- there seems to be ample evidence that the English players turned the
head in, largely covered the hole and blew down, while Boehm advocated
more like the modern classical in line, hole open, blowing across
style. So English flutes would need to be pushed in further for the
same pitch. Note the dramatic increase in both scale and sounding
length in the 20th century. This is partly lowering of pitch, but also
adoption of the modern playing style.
Indeed, something very odd indeed happened in the 20th
century - the flute scale became too long for the pitch at the time.
The 258mm C# to Eb length is taken from an Armstrong Model 90 in the McGee
Flutes Research Collection. While it is sometimes argued that
20th century makers used Boehm's or other early maker's scale, this does
not appear to be the case - the 258mm scale is longer than any of the
others listed. It is quite likely that a later French A= 435 scale
was used, but with the head shortened to make it appear to play at
440. This shoddy work was corrected in the late 20th century by
Cooper et al. Note that the ratio of the C# to Eb lengths for
post-Cooper and for the 1970's flute (255/258) is almost precisely the
same as the ratio of 435 and 440 Hz.
Help Needed!
You'll notice a few gaps in the chart above, in addition to the single
values where a range would be more realistic. If you can help,
please feel free to contact me.
Acknowledgements
Thanks to Charles C. Stevens, amateur flutist, Anaheim, CA for the data
on the Powell flute, and to all the others, too many to mention, who have assisted in compiling this
chart.
Back to McGee-Flutes
Home Page
|
|